Review: These Broken Stars by Amie Kaufman and Meagan Spooner

November 11, 2013 Reviews 3 ★★

Review: These Broken Stars by Amie Kaufman and Meagan SpoonerThese Broken Stars by Amie Kaufman and Meagan Spooner Published by Disney-Hyperion on December 10, 2013
Genres: YA Sci-fi
Pages: 384
Format: eARC
Source: eARC via NetGalley
It's a night like any other on board the Icarus. Then, catastrophe strikes: the massive luxury spaceliner is yanked out of hyperspace and plummets into the nearest planet. Lilac LaRoux and Tarver Merendsen survive. And they seem to be alone.

Lilac is the daughter of the richest man in the universe. Tarver comes from nothing, a young war hero who learned long ago that girls like Lilac are more trouble than they’re worth. But with only each other to rely on, Lilac and Tarver must work together, making a tortuous journey across the eerie, deserted terrain to seek help.

Then, against all odds, Lilac and Tarver find a strange blessing in the tragedy that has thrown them into each other’s arms. Without the hope of a future together in their own world, they begin to wonder—would they be better off staying here forever?

Everything changes when they uncover the truth behind the chilling whispers that haunt their every step. Lilac and Tarver may find a way off this planet. But they won’t be the same people who landed on it.


A timeless love story, THESE BROKEN STARS sets into motion a sweeping science fiction series of companion novels. The Starbound Trilogy: Three worlds. Three love stories. One enemy.

Just about everyone I know has been gushing about this for ages. Between the romance, the feels, the swoons, the “Titanic in space” pitch, and everything else, it sounded great. What I got? Not as great as expected. These Broken Stars is a likable enough story with strongly written characters and equally well-written sci-fi elements, but it doesn’t quite live up to the hype.Please go back to all the phrases/words I brought up when describing the hype. If you’re sharper than me, you can figure out they sounds like they’re all related to a romance. You’re right! You’ll also find what disappointed me so much because the romance is far from what it’s cracked up to be. Though I love Tarver and Lilac as individual characters and Lilac especially as she finds herself after the crash releases her from her father’s iron-fisted rule over her, the two of them together and in love does not work. They hate each other and yet are secretly swooning and then all of a sudden, it’s like someone flipped a switch and they can’t keep their hands off each other. It’s odd.

What makes up the majority of the novel is a survival story. For over 200 pages, Tarver and Lilac crawl through the forests and over mountains to get to the crash site of the Icarus so rescuers can find them more easily. Though my galley’s odd formatting (double-paged, which made it easier to read on my laptop than my Nook) and major college commitments contributed to why it took me so long to read this book, the number-one reason is how dreadfully boring those 200 pages of repetitive traveling and developing romance were. The first 50 pages and the last 100 pages are the only points of major action.

Intersped with our narrators’ chapters are quotes from Tarver’s interrogation. The quotes’ main job is to characterize Tarver and foreshadow through his lies how much changes between him and Lilac–and how he has changed in general–but they made me so angry I nearly DNFed the book at many points. There I am, slogging through a book where the burgeoning romance bores me and nothing has happened for hundreds of pages and like spoilers from the future, the quotes come to tell me they get rescued eventually but I have to keep suffering for now. The quotes laughed at me. THEY LAUGHED AT ME.

Breathe in, breathe out… Sorry about that. Being teased by books in such a way really grinds my gears.

Going back to the sci-fi elements, I don’t know or understand the science behind them (I rarely do with sci-fi novels, honestly), but it sounds fine enough and nothing sticks out to my non-science-y self as pure bull, so it passes my very easy test. Special mention goes to the thoroughly interesting ideas and explanation related to what Tarver and Lilac discover late in the novel. Seriously, more about that, please. Drown me in that science!

Readers who have been looking for a good YA sci-fi romance are surely going to find it here, but anyone reading for something other than that might encounter some disappointment. Tarver and Lilac’s story is finished; the second book will star a new set of characters set in the same world. Depending on how it sounds once more information comes around, I might stick around for it, but for the moment, it looks unlikely.

3 Responses to “Review: These Broken Stars by Amie Kaufman and Meagan Spooner”

  1. Rashika

    I know a couple of people who felt the same way about this book and now I am wondering whether I want to read it or not. Sci-fi romance sounds great except that as someone who once read a great survival story that took place in space I’d end up getting pissed off if all of that was overshadowed by romance.
    I totally get what you mean about the switch thing. Love/hate relationships, as fun as they can be to read about, are hard to pull off and there don’t seem to be many that actually make it believable.

  2. Whitley

    Is it bad that I’ve been waiting for a negative review of this book? The constant praise was starting to smell distinctly fishy…

    That romance sounds awful, but I actually like slogging survivalism, so maybe I’ll give this one a shot when it comes out. Sounds like all the parts that annoyed you would be right up my alley. 😛

Leave a Reply